Why I am still so F%#@*ng French after all these years...
The other day, Reb posted a blog entry titled "10 reasons I know I'm still American." For the record, this blogger has been living in France (she now lives near Lille, actually!) for a good number of years, close to ten, I believe.
This led me to think about the fact that, although I consider myself probably more American than French, there's still a little French dudette lurking inside of me and, at this point, it's a lost cause to think that she will ever leave. Let us, then, discover together what impact her presence has on me and my idiosyncracies.
1. I still count, and do all computations only in French - This may be due to the fact that I memorized my multiplication tables and was forced to practice mental arithmetic (which was sheer torture) to no end while in primary school. By the way, when my daughter learned subtractions and divisions in school, I had a tough time helping her, because I had learned to set them up differently when I was an elementary school kid in France.
2. I never, or very seldom snack - A dictum in my household, when I was growing up, was on ne mange pas entre les repas (one does not eat between meals), and I still abide by that rule.3. I prefer French films to the typical Hollywood fare - Which is interesting, because Reb mentioned that, as an American, she still "didn't get" French films. However, I did not get at all, and found the French comedy Le Père Noël est une ordure to be an outrageously crude piece of trash. I did mention the other day that one of my very favorite French films is Un Air de Famille by Cédric Klapisch, a film that, perhaps, most Americans wouldn't like because it's heavy on dialogues and very thin on action. But it does capture the dynamics of a highly dysfunctional family amazingly well. My favorite American film is probably Christopher Guest's Waiting for Guffman - I know it's no masterpiece, but it's a great comedy!
4. I hate peanut butter and ketchup - I cannot stand peanut butter (although I do like peanuts!), and never found that peanut butter and jelly sandwiches were good. I also would never ever think of putting ketchup on French fries (although I pretty much never eat French fries nowadays), and found it shocking when I realized that my own daughter loved peanut butter, and put ketchup on her fries (as you can see on this picture, Claire really does love ketchup - she drinks it from the bottle!). I always kid my boyfriend because he puts ketchup on omelets. I find that truly disgusting! For the record, I put ketchup and mayonnaise (sort of my own "special sauce") on hamburgers - but I don't eat those very often. I do not put ketchup on any other food. I also find it extremely disgusting to put ketchup on hot dogs (I personally prefer chili! And, believe it or not, in spite of the fact that they are a disgusting food, I do love hot dogs. But I eat them extremely rarely.)5. I prefer eating my salad after, rather than before my main course - Probably because that's when salad is eaten in France. I truly do not like eating my salad before my main course, although I do it whenever I am invited somewhere to eat, or if I eat in a restaurant where the salad is served first.
6. I miss French bread, immensely - My parents always commented that they had never been able to understand why a country such as the United States could not produce decent bread, and made do with the "Wonder" variety. Same here, really. Even what passes as French baguette at Whole Foods is a far cry from its very worst French equivalent.7. I sometimes speak to myself in French, and occasionally swear in French - I have written before here that I find it fairly inconsequential to use profanities in English, probably because they are less emotionally charged for me in that language, because it's not my native tongue. As a result, I swear more typically in English than in French. But, once in a while a nicely nailed putain de merde or bordel proves more effective and cathartic than damn or fuck. Oh, and people constantly ask me if I dream in French. I pretty much never do, but the weirdest dream I ever had, decades ago, was one in which some of my cousins, who do not really speak English, were speaking this language flawlessly. I remember thinking, for the entire duration of this dream, that it was somewhat surreal.
9. I gather that I still have a bit of a French accent - Even though I never really think much about it, some people occasionally make me aware of this fact - for example when they ask me, "where are you from?" I usually respond that I am from a little town in Western Pennsylvania, but I know that they're asking this question because, upon hearing me speak, they detect that I have some sort of a foreign/European accent. I absolutely hate it when it is the first thing that people notice about me.
10. There is still a part of me that even my closest American friends will never understand - I have discussed this before on this blog. That entire part of me that is French is very opaque to my American friends, and only a French expat who has lived in the U.S. as long as I have can understand it.
Labels: Frenchness



9 Comments:
your home is tres french too! so is your blog. thanks for info on french films.
I've adapted to much but not all American terminology and pronunciation: I call a lift an elevator and a pavement a sidewalk; I call people, I don't ring them up; I have learned that in American English "wash up" means oneself and not dishes; and I pronounce "schedule" the American way as "skedule" not "shedule." But after almost 40 years, I still cannot say "tomayto." I've tried, and it sounds so fake when I do it, so I stick to "tomahto." And I shudder inwardly if I have to say "toilet" (which I am having to do a lot at the moment because I am having my bathrooms renovated). In England "toilet" is one of the class-marking words -- the educated say "lavatory."
Oh, and I also can't bring myself to ask for provolone cheese other than with the Italian pronunciation, so I suffer being asked, "You mean provolown?"
Something else -- like you, I don't like it when the first thing people notice about me is my British accent. I know they mean to be flattering and that I am being a real curmudgeon to be annoyed, but it drives me crazy when people say, "I love your accent."
Very interesting! Thanks for the blog fodder; I will try to come up with a list of why I'm still "French" even after living back in my native country.
Or something like that.
As an import (forty plus years ago) to North America (Canada, actually, which is more like the US than Canadians would admit) from a landlocked former British colony in Africa, I identify very much with your alienation from many things American.
When I first arrived, I tried to become as North American as possible in my interests, habits and speech. But as the years passed and I became older, I felt more intensely the loss of my roots. So today I feel less North American than I did many years ago, and I identify with the world at large, rather than with any particular country.
The result is that I look at North Americans (both Canadians and Americans) more and more through the eyes of the outsider (l'etranger?!!), although in appearance I look like the majority. So I feel like a spy in their midst.
I share your revulsion for patriotic flag wavers. HL Mencken called them jelly-bellied flag flappers. No more accurate a description of them have I come across.
To paraphrase Lt. Tuvok from Star Trek: Voyager, "you are who you are, Elisabeth, it is impossible for you to be more or less like yourself".
1. I only work metrically. Units of 10, 5, 2, 1 or 0. All other numbers are pointless.
2. I love snacks! Even the word "snack" makes me feel like I am doing something taboo.
3. Oh honey, I think after a while everyone hates Hollywood.
4. I don't mind them, but I usually alter them.
5. Would like to eat my salad last, but I keep forgetting to tell the waitress to bring it last.
6. I love bread... and pie.
7. I prefer to speak to myself in French, at least I am fairly certain no one knows what I just said. It's also comforting.
8. I have been for many years supplanting what little US patriotism I had pour le patrimoine canadien.
I cringe at the confederate license plates with the deer in the for-ground... or hats or other crap....
9. Practices daily his Québecois, but isn't at all ashamed de son accent pennsylvanie centrale.
10. There's something about everyone what we feel no one else can truly understand.
Thanks for the comments everyone!
Anonymous - Thanks for the compliment, and glad you liked the stuff on French films.
Passante - I think that, once, you wrote about people asking you to "say something" so that they could hear your accent, and you just said that: "say something." I found it hilarious!
Alison - I'd love to see what kind of list you come up with!
Christopher - Interesting observationn about trying to assimilate as much as possible at first, which is what I did. I still consider myself way more American than French, but this blog has led me to embrace - or rather, to contemplate my Frenchness much more than I used to.
Jelly-bellied flag flappers - I love it!
Tim - How do you "alter" peanut butter and ketchup!?!!?!
Also, re. that part of me that none of my very best American friends will never be able to understand - I think it may be bigger than if I had been born and raised in the U.S., because there are things about my French past that I can't really share with them, due to the linguistic and cultural barrier.
That's exactly why I love your blog!
I have lived for 22 years with a Paris born Frenchman, vintage 1936, and it has made my life more than it could every have been if I had stayed monolingual and monocultural. I can't cope with purism. Amalgam is good. Can't get the gold out of the lead or the lead out of the gold. It's so enriching!!!
I loved this post. I live to write one from Le Blanc in the good old future when I'm being never more American than when I'm in France and in the USA everyone is always asking me where I'm from.
Misfits unite!!!
I am catching up with my week's reading because of the holiday and was delighted at this post.
May I say that apart from point 9, all the others, I do think exactly the same?
I have been in the United States for only ten years and a half now, but I know that these won't change anyway, and you proved it so well! :-)
Post a Comment
<< Home